Luminar 4 Review: The Future of Photo Editing? (Updated)
Luminar 4 is carving its own niche in the already saturated world of photo-editing software. The latest creation from Skylum, Luminar 4 is full of easy-to-use editing tools that are perfect for photographers who want to streamline the process of editing their photos. If you want to spend less time in front of a computer, then this is a serious contender. In this Luminar 4 review, we’ll look at exactly what this software is capable of.
There’s plenty of Luminar vs Lightroom talk around photography circles, and I do think that Luminar 4 will be capturing more Lightroom users. Any loose ends of Luminar 3 have been tidied up, bringing a much more stable and exciting editor to use. It feels fresh; it feels new. For the first time ever, I’m actually enjoying using a photo editor.
Download Luminar 4 now at this link and use code NATURETTL for around 10% off!
Luminar 4 review summary:
A completely redesigned, futuristic version of Luminar 4. The software has powerful AI tools that speed up the editing process. The UI is fresh and easy-to-use, with some noticeable speed improvements. Luminar library and export windows are lacking in features, however.
Is Luminar 4 an upgrade to Luminar 3?
Luminar 4 is its own stand-alone software. It is a completely new version in the Luminar series and is, therefore, not a free upgrade to Luminar 3. If you already own Luminar 3, you are able to switch to Luminar 4 at a discounted price.
Read on to decide if investing in the next version is worth it for you!
AI photo editing tools
When I used the previous version of Luminar, I was impressed by how customisable it felt. It was like the software was personal to you, as you could set it up exactly how you wanted. This time around, Luminar 4 feels like it could actually be looking at the future of photo-editing.
AI and automation is here to stay, in all walks of life, and Skylum has brought that into the photography world. Very few people actively enjoy photo-editing, and Luminar 4 looks to reduce the drain on your time caused by photo-editing. To do that, the software has some powerful AI tools. Let’s take a look.
Sky replacement in Luminar 4
One of the really interesting features in Luminar 4 is the sky replacement tool. This tool isn’t for everyone; a lot of you will be thinking that this is sacrilege. However, everyone has different needs and replacing skies is something particularly attractive to photographers dealing with commercial clients.
For example, you’ve shot an image but a client wants a different sky. Well, traditionally you would go through the painstakingly slow process of masking out the sky, and then positioning your sky and relighting the scene.
Luminar 4 has completely turned the tables on this process. You can now switch skies instantly, at the click of a button. Fine-tuning it with a selection of sliders takes seconds. It’s incredibly accurate and impressive, too.
The biggest question – can you use your own sky? Yes. Luminar 4 comes with a number of different skies packaged within it, but you are more than welcome to load in your own sky images and use them. This allows you to keep things unique and stops thousands of people all having the same skies!
Just take a look at this example – this shot of a giraffe was taken last year in South Africa, but the sky is incredibly bland and white.
Perhaps this was shot for a magazine, and they wanted some more punch and colour in the sky for a magazine cover? Normally I would now have to mask out the sky, selecting all of the gaps near the eyelashes, mane, and around the horizon. But with one click, we see almost perfect masking:
Ok, so there are some things we clearly need to adjust. The sky, for example, is completely in focus and the horizon is not perfect. The one click button is just the beginning, though, and there are a number of sliders you can use to easily amend any mismatched issues.
Using the Sky Defocus slider, I can throw out the background to make it match the image properly. Close Gaps allows you to play around with the blending, should anything be slightly off. I moved the horizon down slightly to match the bushes more accurately, and the result is great!
I was incredibly sceptical of this feature when I initially heard about it. I am not one for photo manipulation to this extent, but it is actually extremely impressive and works very well. It’s important to remember that not everyone will want Sky Replacement as part of their workflow, but there are plenty of photographers out there who need it for commercial purposes – or just to have fun!
It is, amazingly, able to pull out the details from between branches. Those tiny gaps where the sky only partially penetrates through a tree – it’ll find them, and it’ll mask them. That’s crazy!
As you can see from above, the software actually relights the scene. What it can’t do, of course, is move shadows. So you need to use skies with the sun in the correct place. You can always flip the sky if needed.
The above image of the bear is lit with flash, and so the sky change is probably not ideal for this scene but I wanted to illustrate just how good it is at masking the sky when there are many trees and branches to deal with. Big thumbs up from an initially sceptical reviewer!
The limitation seems to be when dealing with reflections. Unsurprisingly, it is unable to pop a sky into reflections in water or on buildings. Maybe that’s something we’ll see in a future Luminar 5, but for now you can’t proper sky swap in Luminar 4. You could, of course, swap out the sky and then make manual manipulations to the reflection if you so wished.
Download Luminar 4: Use code NATURETTL for around 10% off!
AI augmented sky
As of version 4.2 of Luminar 4, a new tool called AI Augmented Sky has come onto the scene. Working similarly to Sky Replacement, this tool allows you to inject objects into your sky rather than swapping it out entirely.
Once again, this tool is for creativity and artistry rather than “traditional” photography. Using stock images, I was able to play with this tool and see how it behaves. Firstly, I started with a simple adjustment using one of the Augmented Sky presets.
By adding a flock of passing indescript birds to the scene, it definitely improves the image in my opinion. The software has automatically detected the sky and allowed me to place the birds in situ. Granted, this is a fairly simple image and object insertion to work with.
The above animation shows how as I reposition the birds they do not overlap any of the landscape. Luminar 4 appears to be very capable of isolating the sky from anything else, even with details on the horizon that break the skyline.
The capabilities of this tool mean that you can introduce any of your own images as objects, too. As long as it is either places on a transparent or black background, you can import this into Luminar to use as your very own Augmented Sky asset.
Consequently, we are bound to see some “overly creative” additions to skylines. However, the beauty of this tool is really in the subtle. Like with Sky Replacement, I can see this being very useful for commercial photographers that need to ensure an image is exactly what a client wants.
Take a look at this more complex image. There are branches covering the sky and a lot of mountain coverage.
Luminar 4 was capable of masking out the tree’s branches and allowing me to place the moon straight behind it. All those tiny gaps in the branches were instantly accounted for.
What I did notice, however, was that it wasn’t capable of picking out the clouds. Objects placed in the sky will appear in front of clouds that are already there. So, it seems that you either need to choose an area without clouds to add objects, or a sky without clouds. You could, of course, swap out a sky using AI Sky Replacement before then working with Augmented Sky if needed.
Personally, I think this is a great tool to have. Whilst it isn’t something I’d necessarily use in my own work, I know that if a client specifically wanted an Aurora Borealis above their house in the Mediterranean, then I could definitely deliver it – astronomically accurate or not.
This is a tool that you can use to adjust the apparent sharpness of an image without actually sharpening it. It’s a contrast adjustment, boosting details in the background without negatively impacting your subject.
Unlike with a sharpening tool, AI structure does not introduce any noise, halos, or artefacts into the shot. You can also apply both a positive and negative value, meaning that instead of boosting the apparent sharpness of your background (a positive value on the slider), you can actually throw it more out of focus (negative value).
Here’s an example using a subtle negative value, in an effort to separate the subject a little more from the background.
Essentially, it is an intelligent clarity slider. When you are first experimenting with AI structure, it is important to note that the “Amount” slider denotes the area of the image being affected, and the “Boost” slider denotes the intensity of the adjustment.
Perhaps most useful for landscape or portrait photographers, AI structure is best used subtly in nature photography in my opinion.
AI skin & portrait enhancer
If you photograph people, then the new AI skin and portrait tools will be a very welcome addition for you. With the ability to quickly, and intelligently, airbrush your subjects, the editing process is much quicker.
As I’m a wildlife photographer, and not a portrait photographer, I bought some stock images to experiment with and see how these tools work. Even I can tell that this is pretty amazing. Check out the image of a man with heavy blemishing.
Now, usually you would go through and gently remove the blemishes. Not with AI Skin Enhancer – just tick the “defects removal” tool and adjust the slider to suit. Instantly, the skin is cleaned up.
That’s impressive. Again, the Amount slider adjusts how intense the tool is. You can ram the slider all the way to 100 for a very “airbrushed” look, or keep it in the low digits for a more natural feel (which is what I’ve done here, at a value of 27).
Look in the hairline, just above the ear. The tool has attempted to remove a spot under his hair, but whilst the detection of this is great it has left a noticeable patch. So at this point you would want to apply a mask over that area to stop the tool removing it, and instead apply your own manual intervention for this tricky area.
Where things get really scary is when you’re tidying up an image of someone with both freckles and spots. The software almost perfectly removes just the spots and blemishes, leaving freckles intact. In this example, a couple of moles are removed, however this is easily masked out in a small fine-tune adjustment if needed.
On some of the images I tested, it did seem to leave noticeable patches when masking very complex skin structures. For example, when there were dense freckles on someone’s face it struggled to leave a smooth texture where there had once been a blemish. This tended to coincide with a low quality image, though, that had imperfections in the shot itself.
AI vertical alignment
One particularly interesting tool on the horizon is the AI vertical alignment tool. We’re told this is coming in version 4.1 of Luminar (a free upgrade to Luminar 4). It will allow you to instantly correct your horizons and straighten things up in your image.
Beyond AI editing tools
Ok, AI not for you? So what else does Luminar 4 have? Well, it continues to benefit from layer editing. This allows you to stack your edits in adjustment layers, making Luminar 4 almost like a hybrid of Lightroom and Photoshop.
Being able to edit in layers allows you to create more complex adjustments, should you wish to, and dip in and out of your edit as you see fit. If you like to take your time with your editing, you can still do that with Luminar 4 – the AI tools are not compulsory – and the layers will help you do this.
Everything you would expect to be there, is there. Advanced masking with brushes, radial, gradient, and even luminosity masks are possible. The latter allows you to mask the image based on the brightness, which is a great way to quickly mask out skies and other highlights.
Coming in a future update, lens profiles will soon be here. This means that you will be able to tick a box to remove the likes of vignetting and any bevel in the image caused by the glass in a particular lens. Each adjustment will be unique to each lens used, and a definite welcome addition to Luminar.
Adjustments held in Luminar
Since there is a Library attached to Luminar 4, your adjustments remain within the software until you export them. For example, you are able to make some edits and then close down the software without saving any changes. Once you come back, the edits are still there; it is a non-destructive process, just like with Lightroom.
Luminar still has a wealth of presets, which they are now calling “Looks,” that you can apply to your images. This is a good way to get a quick starting point to your image, or to completely remove the editing process (although no one would suggest relying entirely on a preset).
You can also make your own adjustments and save a custom Look, allowing you to apply to across a range of images if you desire.
The user interface
Whilst Luminar 3 was very customisable, there was a risk it was a little complex. With so many options and filters to apply, it lost a level of simplicity. Luminar 4 has addressed this by fixing the layout, providing you with 5 different sidebars of tools. This allows you to select the appropriate range of tools for your image. You can, of course, move between them to use different tools if required.
It is now much neater, and it feels easier to navigate the editing process.
One thing I mentioned in my review of Luminar 3 was that the export window is very simple. Sadly, Luminar 4 has not brought any updates in this area. The options for exporting images are still fairly restrictive, and you can’t make export presets. Hopefully this is something they will address, but as it stands there are no updates in that area.
Both users of Luminar 3 and prospective Luminar 4 users will be pleased to hear that the ability to edit the metadata of your photos (that’s the caption, keywords, etc) is coming to both versions of Luminar. We’ve been told early 2020 for that, and I’ll be updating the review in due course.
There are few improvements to the Library section of Luminar 4 as of yet. This is partly because Skylum is not looking to replicate Lightroom, and instead is positioning itself as its own beast.
Still, some areas have been tidied up and we will also be able to search for images by their metadata once that update is released early 2020.
Speed and performance
Some users reported issues with Luminar 3 being slow, particularly those working on a Windows computer. Personally, I never experienced such problems and Windows users I spoke to did not have issues with the speed of the software.
The big factor here was, of course, the build of each machine being used to run Luminar. If the computer doesn’t have the necessary hardware, things will be slow. However, with that in mind, Skylum has worked to bring equilibrium between both the Windows and Mac versions of Luminar 4.
We are told both Mac and Windows users will see the same features, and there are speed and performance boosts built into Luminar 4.
In my personal experience using the software for this Luminar 4 review, adjustments are quick and easy. There doesn’t seem to be any delay when applying small adjustments, and minimal delay when applying the larger AI tools.
Is Luminar better than Lightroom?
This is a question that a lot of you reading this Luminar 4 review might be asking. The truth is, the two are different beasts. Skylum has always been very clear that they are not looking to make their own version of Adobe’s Lightroom, but instead want to carve its own position in the industry.
Lightroom is arguably the better choice for organising huge libraries of photos. If you’re only looking for workflow management, then you’ll probably stick with Lightroom. However, if you are looking to make editing a quicker and more streamlined process, then Luminar 4 is for you.
Keep in mind, though, that Luminar does have its own cataloging function. It’s just not as fledged out as that of Lightroom. So, consider the trade-off for the better editing tools. Plus, Skylum rolls out a lot of updates and they are updating the cataloging feature to make it even better.
In all honesty, when I first read that Luminar was bringing AI tools and a lot of “futuristic” updates I was sceptical. In fact, I was a little disappointed thinking it would all be gimmicky and not work very well at all.
Boy, was I wrong. I’ve had the software for a couple of weeks, and I’ve completely U-turned on my initial thoughts. The tools do work – and they work really well. I am extremely impressed, and clearly Skylum has taken the necessary time and money to invest in Luminar 4 to create a serious contender.
If you’re on the fence, I would say that it’s a bargain. There’s no subscription fee, and with an affordable one-off price (retailing at €89) you can’t go wrong. Once you’ve bought it, you own Luminar 4 forever. The “usual” photo-editors feel monotonous and old compared to Luminar 4 – and Skylum has breathed some necessary life into the photo-editing process.
You can download Luminar 4 from the Skylum website, and use code NATURETTL for around 10% off.
Frequently Asked Questions
By now we have had a number of questions from our Luminar 4 review, so here are some quick answers to help you.
Yes – Luminar 4 is capable of editing both raw and JPEG files from a wide variety of cameras.
Yes. Luminar 4 has a non-destructive editing process, meaning that you aren’t going to overwrite your original raw files.
Yes. Luminar 4 is a completely new piece of software, with significantly different features to Luminar 3.
Yes. At the time of testing, Luminar 4 is actually performing faster than the latest generation of Lightroom Classic for us. This may not be the case for all users, though.
If you are dealing with a huge catalogue and require a professional workflow for keywording etc. for stock websites, then Lightroom is a better choice. But if you are looking to speed up your editing process and have a more enjoyable experience tweaking your images, Luminar 4 is a good choice.
The two are completely different beasts. Photoshop has a strong suite of editing tools, but is often overcomplicated for photographers looking to edit images. Only in some situations is Photoshop actually necessary.
Yes – Luminar is available in the USA, UK, and all other countries globally.